If you decide to drop dental PPO contracts, the fee schedule is the easy part of the decision. The harder part is the week after the notice goes out, when patients call to ask whether you still take their insurance. This guide covers the marketing and communication side of the move: the math that tells you how many patients you can afford to lose, what to say on the phone and in a letter, and a sequence that puts new-patient channels in place before anyone is notified.
The short answer: you can drop dental PPO plans without a revenue hit when the share of that plan’s patients you keep stays above 1 minus the plan’s write-off rate, assuming the patients who stay pay your full fee. At a 30% write-off the breakeven is 70% retention. At 50% it is 50%. No source offers a reliable universal attrition number, so your own plan data matters more than any benchmark.
What changes for patients when you leave a PPO network
Leaving a network does not cancel a patient’s dental benefits. It changes how the claim gets paid. Delta Dental’s own explanation, written for employers, says patients who see a non-network dentist are typically charged the full price upfront, then submit a claim and wait for a check covering the insured portion. It also notes they can be balance billed when the dentist’s fee exceeds the plan’s maximum allowance. In-network patients pay only their share and file nothing.
Delta Dental’s worked example shows the size of the gap. On a $1,000 procedure covered at 50%, the member pays $300 at a PPO dentist and $538 at a non-network dentist, assuming a $925 plan allowance for the non-network visit. Allowances vary by plan, so the gap is different for every patient. That variation is the reason a single form letter underperforms, and it is why the segmentation table later in this guide matters.
For a sense of how common the move is, an American Dental Association Health Policy Institute poll from February 2023 found that about 16% of dentists had dropped out of some insurance networks since January 1 of that year, and the dropped networks covered 17.5% of their patient bases on average. The poll did not report what happened to those patients. Read 17.5% as a yardstick for exposure, not a forecast of loss. If the plan you want to leave covers 40% of your schedule, your exposure is more than double the typical case, and the plan needs to be more careful than average.
Drop dental PPO plans only after you know your breakeven retention

Start with the production a plan’s patients generate at your full fee schedule. The plan’s fee schedule collects less, and the gap is the write-off. If patients who stay pay your full fee, you collect the same revenue after you drop dental PPO participation as before once you keep a share of them equal to one minus the write-off rate. If you offer stayers a courtesy discount, the target rises. The formula is:
Breakeven retention = (1 − write-off rate) ÷ (1 − courtesy discount)
Here is a worked example with illustrative inputs. A plan’s patients generate $400,000 a year at your full fees, and the plan pays $280,000 after a 30% write-off. You break even at 70% retention ($280,000 ÷ $400,000). Add a 10% courtesy discount for patients who stay, and the practice collects $360,000 at full retention, so the breakeven moves to 77.8%.
| Plan write-off | No discount | 10% courtesy discount | 15% courtesy discount |
|---|---|---|---|
| 30% | 70.0% | 77.8% | 82.4% |
| 40% | 60.0% | 66.7% | 70.6% |
| 50% | 50.0% | 55.6% | 58.8% |
These figures come from the formula above, not from a survey, so replace the inputs with the write-off from your own ledger. One practice owner writing in Dental Economics reported PPO write-offs of 30% to 50%, which makes those three rows a sensible range to test.
The formula leaves things out in both directions. It flatters leaving because patients who go also stop costing you lab fees and supplies, and their chair time can go to higher-fee patients. It punishes leaving because marketing costs money, some patients defer treatment, and a smaller patient base produces fewer referrals. Treat the result as a floor check, not a green light. If a plan’s breakeven sits above what you realistically expect to keep, it is not the plan to leave first. Leave the plan with the lowest breakeven, not the one you dislike most.
On expected attrition, the same Dental Economics author prepared to lose up to 30% of his PPO patients, reported losing well under that, and heard from only two or three patients who complained. He also kept one plan within 15% of full fees. That is one practice’s account rather than a study, so it marks the optimistic end of the range. A Henry Schein article on the subject says only that there is a risk of patient loss and gives no figure. The sensible planning stance is to assume some loss, size it with the table, and measure the real number after your first exit.
Should you drop dental PPO plans all at once or one at a time?
One at a time, starting with the lowest breakeven. A front desk can only hold so many new conversations in a week, and each exit gives you a real retention figure to use in the next decision. Staging also keeps part of your insurance-driven new-patient flow alive while your replacement channels ramp up. If contract renewal dates force several exits close together, sequence the patient communication plan by plan so no patient receives two confusing notices.
Build new-patient channels before you send the notice
Insurance directories send some patients your way, and leaving removes that listing. Check how much it matters before assuming. The Dental Economics author found that only 6% to 7% of his new patients reported coming through insurance on the intake question. Your number may be higher or lower, and your intake forms or call tracking can tell you in an afternoon. Then put the replacement in place first:
- Google Business Profile. Prepare an update that says you are out of network with the plan, that you file claims, and that estimates are free, and publish it when the patient notice goes out.
- An insurance page on your website. State plainly which plans you are out of network with, how claims and estimates work, and what a visit typically involves, using the same wording as the phone script below.
- A steady flow of reviews. Ask satisfied patients on a regular schedule and keep to the platform’s rules; our guide to Google’s review policy for dental practices covers what is allowed.
- Search campaigns on non-insurance terms. Implants, emergency visits and cosmetic work attract patients who choose on trust and availability rather than network status.
- A dental membership plan for uninsured patients. It gives patients without coverage a clear price, which becomes more valuable once more of your patient base pays out of network.
Segment patients before you message them
Because out-of-network reimbursement varies by plan, a patient with a generous plan and a patient with almost no out-of-network benefit need different conversations. Some plans, such as capitation or HMO-style plans, may pay nothing outside the network, so check each plan type before you write the letter.
| Segment | What they need to hear | Best channel |
|---|---|---|
| Treatment in progress or accepted but unscheduled | What happens to their plan of care and cost, in writing, with a clear date | Personal call from the office manager or treating dentist |
| Recall patients on plans with decent out-of-network benefits | You will file the claim, reimbursement varies by plan, and a written estimate comes before the visit | Letter and email, then a call to non-responders |
| Patients on plans with little or no out-of-network benefit | An honest account of how benefits may apply, plus membership, financing or a referral to an in-network practice | Personal call |
| Overdue patients with no visit in over a year | A short, friendly invitation to return | Email, or text with documented consent |
| New callers | The same two-sentence answer every time | Phone, trained front desk |
A phone script and patient letter you can adapt
The question you will hear most is “Do you take my insurance?” Decide on one answer and have every team member say it the same way. The Dental Economics author recommends a real conversation with the team, followed by role-playing patient questions, before anything goes out. Here is a script to start from:
“We’re no longer in network with [Plan], but you can still use your benefits here. We’ll file the claim for you, and before any treatment we’ll give you a written estimate of what your plan typically covers and what you’d pay. Would you like us to check your benefits before your visit?”
Do not promise a reimbursement amount, and do not apologize for your fees. The estimate does the reassuring. For the letter, keep the tone matter-of-fact:
Subject: A change in how we work with [Plan]
Dear [First name],
Beginning [date], [Practice name] will no longer be in network with [Plan]. Your dental benefits do not go away: you can still use them at our office. We will submit claims for you, and before any treatment we will give you a written estimate of the cost and what your plan typically pays.
Because each plan reimburses out-of-network care differently, your out-of-pocket cost may differ from what you pay today. If you have treatment planned or in progress, please call [phone] by [date] so we can go over your options together.
[Name], [Title]
Leave out criticism of the plan, reimbursement promises and any pressure to book. If you plan to text the same message, confirm you have documented consent first; our overview of TCPA texting rules for practices explains what to check. Review your contract’s termination and notice terms and ask your attorney about state requirements before sending anything. This guide covers marketing and communication, not legal advice.

A 90-day sequence to drop dental PPO plans without losing momentum
Count back from your termination effective date, and adjust the dates if your contract requires a longer or shorter notice period.
- Weeks 12 to 10 before the effective date: pull each plan’s write-off, patient count and new-patient source, calculate the breakeven, choose the first plan to leave, and read the contract’s notice terms.
- Weeks 10 to 7: build the insurance page and the Google Business Profile update as drafts, start steady review requests, launch non-insurance search campaigns, and set up the membership plan offer.
- Weeks 7 to 5: train the team, role-play the five most likely patient questions, and set up the estimate and out-of-network claim workflow.
- Weeks 5 to 3: call patients with treatment in progress and your most active families personally.
- Weeks 3 to 1: send the letter and email to everyone else on the plan, then publish the website and Business Profile updates.
- Weeks 1 to 8 after: track calls, bookings and cancellations, phone patients who go quiet, and start a patient reactivation sequence for anyone who has not rebooked after about 60 days. Compare actual retention with your breakeven, then decide on the next plan.
Mistakes that cost practices patients when they drop dental PPO plans
- Announcing before the team can answer. A patient who calls the day the letter lands and gets a hesitant answer assumes the worst.
- Discounting without a written policy. If stayers get a courtesy discount, decide the amount and who qualifies in advance, so that two patients are not quoted different fees for the same crown.
- Writing about the insurer instead of the patient’s next step. The message should end with what the patient does next, not with a complaint about reimbursement.
- Skipping the overdue list. Patients who have not visited in a year are the most likely to read a network change as a reason to stay away.
- Not measuring. Without retention numbers after the first exit, the second exit is a guess.
Deciding to drop dental PPO plans is a retention project with a pricing decision attached. Practices that run the breakeven for each plan, stage the exits, and make sure the front desk says one consistent thing give themselves the best chance of keeping the patients they most want to keep.
Frequently asked questions about leaving a dental PPO
How many patients will we lose when we drop dental PPO plans?
No reliable universal figure exists. One practice owner planned for up to 30% of PPO patients and reported losing well under that, but that is a single account. Calculate your breakeven retention from your own write-off, then track actual retention for eight weeks after the first plan you leave.
Should we drop dental PPO plans all at once?
Staging is usually safer. Start with the plan that has the lowest breakeven retention, measure what happens, and use that result to decide on the next plan. Exiting one plan at a time also keeps front-desk conversations manageable and preserves part of your insurance-driven new-patient flow while replacement channels grow.
Can we still file claims for patients after leaving a network?
Many out-of-network practices still submit claims for patients as a courtesy. Delta Dental notes that non-network patients typically pay upfront and are reimbursed afterward, so filing on their behalf reduces friction. Check your plan contracts and state rules, and tell patients clearly who is paid and when.
Do we still need to advertise if we are out of network?
Yes. Leaving a network removes your insurance directory listing, so new patients have to find you another way. Strengthen your Google Business Profile, reviews, website insurance page and non-insurance search campaigns before the notice goes out, and use intake data to see how many new patients actually came from the directory.
What do we say when a patient asks, “Do you take my insurance?”
Tell the truth in two sentences: you are not in network, but the patient can still use benefits, you will file the claim, and you will provide a written estimate before treatment. Do not promise a reimbursement amount. Train every team member to give the same answer and role-play it before launch.


